Are the Rules for Painting Ceilings Wrong? DIY Tips & 6 examples of Flat vs Eggshell Sheen so you can pick the Best Ceiling Paint Finish!
And, I have a video walkthrough of my home showing why I made the switch from flat to using eggshell on ceilings.
Best Ceiling Paint Finish: Flat vs Eggshell
I know guys, I’ve heard the old rule about only using a flat paint sheen on ceilings. That rule has been around for decades.
I’m not sure how that ever became a rule. Or who the person was that made that rule up.
I’m kind of imagining some crazy Madmen-style 1960’s advertising firm coming up with these rules to sell more paint. Personally though, I think a flat ceiling paint finish looks boring on most ceilings.
Some links on this post are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Using a flat paint sheen on ceilings gives them a dull finish that can darken the feel of a room. I always feel like a flat sheen on a ceiling makes the ceiling feel lower and looks unfinished too.
Which is a shame. It’s a missed opportunity when it comes to adding extra style to your home. Here’s 6 examples of Flat vs Eggshell Paint Sheen on Ceilings in my home to show you the difference.
Table of contents
- Best Ceiling Paint Finish: Flat vs Eggshell
- What Sheen Should Ceiling Paint Be?
- Eggshell VS Flat Ceiling Paint Finish
- Which Paint Sheen Looks Best on a Textured or Popcorn Ceiling
- Which Paint Sheen on Crown Molding
What Sheen Should Ceiling Paint Be?
Honestly, you should ignore the old design rules about which paint sheens to use in different parts of your house. Instead, go with what you think looks best.
After years of remodeling homes, I think eggshell is the best paint sheen on ceilings.
And, to explain why I love eggshell sheen on ceilings, I have a pictures of ceilings in my house to show you the huge difference between a flat and eggshell sheen on ceilings.
But, there are some ceilings that should still be painted with a flat sheen.
The dull finish of flat paint doesn’t reflect light and always seems to make rooms feel smaller and unfinished in most houses.
When a ceiling has a subtle sheen it draws my eyes up and makes any room feel lighter, brighter, larger, and more welcoming.
Let’s get to those examples of why I think eggshell is the best paint sheen on ceilings!
Eggshell VS Flat Ceiling Paint Finish
Before and After Ceiling Makeover #1
Let’s start with the ceiling paint in the room I’m remodeling right now. You might have seen peeks of this ceiling in my How to Paint Built In Bookshelves and Cabinets post. It’s the ceiling in our Family Room.
It was already a nicely designed drop ceiling with beautiful wood trim. But, the paint always felt wrong to me. Have a look at the before photo.
The ceiling was somehow missing something that made that beautiful trim look boring. I thought about adding more wood trim to the ceiling.
But, in the end, I decided to switch the ceiling paint to eggshell sheen to see if that fixed my boring ceiling.
And, I think it 100% improved the look and feel of this ceiling. What do you think? The paint color is called Vermont Cream by Behr paint.
The new eggshell ceiling paint finish reflects light, draws the eyes up, and makes the ceiling feel somehow higher.
This simple paint sheen change on the ceiling makes the whole room feel lighter, brighter, and more inviting. I can’t wait to get the floor and furniture in to start enjoying this great room again.
You can see all of the Before and After Family Room Makeover pictures from this room now. Here’s a sneak peek.
Best Paint Finish For Ceilings: Video Tour
You can see a tour of the flat vs eggshell ceiling paint finish in this room and a few other rooms in my house in this video from my YouTube channel.
Whenever I’m remodeling or updating a room, the ceiling is always part of the design plan. I love a good statement ceiling. Even when that means endless days on a ladder of installing wood trim over my head. 😉
I have 4 more before and examples of eggshell sheen ceilings in my home. 3 of these include DIY wood trim or paneling detail too.
Let’s start with my favorite ceiling makeover that really shows why I think eggshell is the best paint sheen on ceilings.
Before and After Ceiling Makeover #2
Here’s a look at our home office ceiling with a flat ceiling paint sheen.
After I did a full remodel on this room, switching to an Eggshell ceiling paint sheen added so much shine and a fresh new look to the ceiling in this room.
Before and After Ceiling Makeover #3
This Dining Room ceiling originally had the same wood trim and drop ceiling design as our Family Room (example 1).
Since you can see our Dining Room from our Foyer, I wanted this ceiling to be extra special as a first impression when people visit our house.
So, I added a Simple DIY Coffered Ceiling to this ceiling, using 1×4’s and cove molding to give this ceiling a fresh new look.
After using caulk and wood filler on the wood trim, I painted the entire ceiling with the same eggshell sheen white paint I used on the Family Room ceiling. It’s Behr’s Vermont Cream color.
This beautiful coffered ceiling looks amazing, especially with the new wood trim paneling I installed in our foyer after I removed an arched doorway between that foyer and our family room.
Everything is coming together nicely in these rooms. 🙂
Before and After Ceiling Makeover #4
Here’s another massive improvement that only involved a ceiling paint sheen change.
We have a huge ceiling that goes over our Foyer, upstairs Hallway, and Living Room. And by huge I mean it’s probably 18′ x 50′. It’s massive.
So, that big ceiling really catches your attention. The builder did a nice job of installing beautiful crown molding and dental molding around the ceiling.
But again, the flat ceiling paint sheen felt boring. It made me want to look away from the ceiling that took up so much space.
And, after 20 years, that crown molding needed a new coat of paint too.
So, I spent a week on scaffolding painting the ceiling and crown molding to turn that ceiling into the eye-catching feature it deserved to be.
Next up is a look at the finished eggshell ceiling and crown molding paint. For this ceiling, I really wanted to accentuate that beautiful crown molding.
So, I painted the crown molding with Behr’s Polished Pearl in Eggshell Sheen. And, I painted the ceiling in a slightly darker creamy beige to make the crown POP!
That ceiling paint color is actually the exact same color that I have on the walls. But, the shadows on the ceiling make it look a bit darker than the walls.
The color on the walls and ceiling here is Behr’s Sandstone Cove in Eggshell Sheen.
Before and After Ceiling Makeover #5
Our Master Bedroom is another example of a big change that was made with wood trim and paneling.
This ceiling had a beautiful vaulted design but a bad drywall job and ugly flat ceiling paint really made it more of a problem than a beautiful feature.
I decided that the best way to accentuate that vaulted ceiling would be to install plywood paneling and trim around the angled sides of the vaulted ceiling.
I love how that trim draws your eyes up and really makes the room feel grand. You can see the details of this DIY Vaulted Ceiling Makeover here.
I painted the wood panels and trim in Behr’s Polished Pearl in Eggshell. And, again, I used Behr’s Sandstone Cove in Eggshell Sheen on the walls and ceiling.
Those are the same colors I used in the Living Room in the last example.
I love how the light colored paint scheme in our home has completely transformed this house. The rooms feel so much lighter, brighter, and more inviting.
Before and After Ceiling Makeover #6
The last before and after example of the best paint sheen to use on ceilings is from our Master Bathroom. I gave our Master Bathroom a Full Remodel a couple years ago.
It was another room with an underwhelming feature ceiling and a boring, flat ceiling paint sheen.
The ceiling has a pitched center with lots of level changes and a soffit hiding plumbing. That made the ceiling in this room feel confused and not quite right.
After a lot of planning and thinking, I decided to go with a DIY Plywood Plank Ceiling in this room. The planks bring the different levels of the ceiling together, turning it into a design feature.
And, since I used plywood to make the planks, it was really a low cost makeover.
I painted the ceiling planks in our Master Bathroom with Behr’s Polished Pearl in Eggshell Sheen. The original ceiling was just a boring, builders grade flat ceiling paint sheen.
So, what do you think? Should ceiling paint be flat or eggshell?
That’s it for my examples. But, I have answers to a few common questions to help you decide which is the best ceiling paint sheen.
Which Paint Sheen Looks Best on a Textured or Popcorn Ceiling
The only time I’d recommend a flat paint sheen on a ceiling is for a heavily textured ceiling.
If you have a popcorn ceiling or heavy texture on your ceiling, that you don’t like, I’d paint that ceiling with a flat paint sheen.
A flat paint sheen is the best at hiding some of that texture. Like I mentioned at the beginning of this post, a flat paint sheen doesn’t reflect light. It just looks like a uniform color across the entire ceiling.
Which is ideal when you want to distract attention away from an ugly texture on a ceiling.
If you painted a textured ceiling with an eggshell or shinier sheen, that light would reflect off different bits of that texture drawing attention to that unwanted texture on the ceiling.
So, if you do have a popcorn, be sure to follow the rules for safely painting a popcorn ceiling. If you touch it after it is wet, the popcorn texture can easily fall off.
Which Paint Sheen on Crown Molding
If you read the before and after makeover details above, you probably already know my answer to this question. I like to use eggshell paint sheen on crown molding and all of the other trim in my home.
The old rule of thumb was to use semi-gloss or gloss on molding and trim in a home. Again, I ignore that rule of thumb and use what I like.
I prefer the subtle sheen with eggshell. It seems more casual than a semi-gloss or gloss sheen. More livable.
I know this won’t be true of every home, but I always think a glossy sheen in a home feels too formal and old fashioned.
People always say that glossy sheens are easier to wipe clean too. I do think that flat paint sheens are hard to wipe clean. The texture is just a bit too rough. It holds on to dirt and oils.
But eggshell sheen and shinier sheens have always been very easy for me to wipe clean.
And, that is super important with my 2 boys. They are constantly leaving marks on our eggshell sheen walls and trim. I can easily wipe it away with a dishrag or Clorox wipes.
That’s it for my thoughts on the Best Paint Sheen on Ceilings. I hope all of these examples helped you figure out what sheen for ceiling paint you’ll use.
More DIY Home Projects for You!
Looking for more DIY Tips and Home Maintenance Videos? Check out this playlist full of great DIY’s on my YouTube Channel.
Streaming TV has so much great content, I’ll never have to watch a rerun again. And, I’m saving so much money every year. Here’s everything you need to know about how do I get rid of cable and still watch TV.
New to do some Furniture Painting? Here’s How to Paint Furniture for Beginners, with everything you need to know to get started.
And, if it is time to Stain your Front Door, check out these steps for how I restain a front door without stripping it or removing it. 🙂
You might also like this DIY for How to Whiten Tile Grout. It’s a Game Changer!
Here’s how to clean your car seats at home…even when they’re disgusting, this works.
Feeling inspired? Now that you’ve seen which is the Best Paint Finish For Ceilings, good luck with your project.
Don’t forget to sign up for the Abbotts At Home email newsletter to get DIY, Remodeling, and Crafty ideas in your inbox.